LEGALDIGMLEGALDIGM
    ← Danmark
    Beta
    RETSINFO 9975/2025

    RETSINFO 9975/2025 — Indskud i Trust - fondsbeskatningslovens § 3 A, stk. 1.

    Beta. Juridisk information, ikke juridisk rådgivning. Tjek den officielle kilde for den gældende tekst.

    Analysér denne lov med AI
    Tekst I spørgsmål 1 ønskedes det bekræftet, at spørgers indskud i "Trusten" var omfattet af fondsbeskatningslovens § 3 A, stk. 1. Det var en betingelse for at være omfattet af fondsbeskatningslovens § 3 A, stk. 1, at trusten efter dansk skattepraksis kunne anses for et selvstændigt skattesubjekt. Efter trustens vedtægt var der både en uafhængig trustee og en uafhængig protektor. Dette kunne indikere, at trusten var et selvstændigt skattesubjekt. Spørger havde dog også udarbejdet letter of wishes inden trusten blev stiftet, og spørger kunne senere ændre letter of wishes. Trusten måtte, under hensyn til at spørger kunne ændre letter of wishes, anses for transparent efter dansk skattepraksis, uanset at der var en uafhængig trustee og uafhængig protektor. Spørgsmålet kunne derfor ikke bekræftes. I spørgsmål 2 ønskedes det bekræftet, at ligningsloven § 16 K ikke fandt anvendelse for spørger i forhold til afkast på aktiver indskudt i Trusten. Da trusten, jf. besvarelsen af spørgsmål 1, var transparent i forhold til spørger, fandt ligningslovens § 16 K, ikke anvendelse. Spørgsmålet kunne derfor bekræftes. Skatterådsmøde 27. maj 2025 - SKM2025. 326. SR Spørgsmål: 1. Kan Skatterådet bekræfte, at Spørgers indskud i Trusten omfattes af fondsbeskatningslovens § 3 A, stk. 1? 2. Kan Skatterådet bekræfte, at ligningsloven § 16 K ikke finder anvendelse for Spørger i forhold til afkast på aktiver indskudt i Trusten? Svar: 1. Nej 2. Ja Beskrivelse af de faktiske forhold Spørger har stiftet og indskudt midler i "Trusten", der er registreret i X-land. Trusten beskattes ikke i X-land eller i nogen anden jurisdiktion og trusten er således stiftet i et lavskatteland. Trusten er etableret som en uigenkaldelig trust, hvor stifteren Spørger hverken kan tilbagekalde midler fra trusten eller råde over de indskudte midler. Dette fremgår af de fremsendte dokumenter, herunder: - Declaration of Trust dateret [dato udeladt], og - Instrument of Addition dateret [dato udeladt], og - Letter of Wishes underskrevet af Spørger. Spørgers hensigt er, at Trusten opfylder betingelserne i fondsbeskatningslovens § 3 A, herunder at afkast fra trusten ikke skal beskattes hos Spørger efter ligningslovens § 16 K. Vi har allerede indsendt blanket vedr. 20 pct. afgift efter fondsbeskatningslovens § 3 A, stk. 1. Spørger påtænker at foretage yderligere betydelige indskud til Trusten og ønsker derfor klarhed i forhold til den danske skattemæssige behandling. Af et letter of Wishes 2024 fra Spørger fremgår følgende: STRICTLY PRIVATE AND CONFIDENTIAL To the Trustees of the Trust LETTER OF WISHES I am the Settlor of the Trust made between: (i) me and (ii) Trust (Guernsey) Limited (the "Trust"). As Trustees, you have wide powers and discretions under the Trust to deal with the Trust property and distribute Trust capital and income among the class of beneficiaries. I am writing to set out my wishes as to the administration of the Trust and, in particular, the application of income and capital for the benefit of the beneficiaries. This letter is by way of guidance only and does not seek to fetter in any way the exercise of your powers and discretions, although I trust you will give my wishes full and proper regard. I would like you to consider my daughter, as the principal beneficiary of the Trust during her lifetime. You should look to her for guidance on all aspects concerning the Trust, including investment and the retention or distribution of both income and capital and feel free to make distributions to her of either income or capital. In the event of her death, without her leaving subsequent guidance to the contrary, I would like you to hold the Trust Fund primarily for the benefit of her children in equal shares following the guidance set out below. Following her death, you should look to her son, her husband and the father of her children, for guidance on all aspects concerning the Trust, including when considering making provision for her children and descendants. In principle, suggest that, up to the age of thirty, funds are used primarily for each child's education (including fees/living expenses for higher education up to the level they wish to pursue), the provision of a comfortable home and any medical needs, although should there be any need to provide funds for general living expenses, to ensure that each enjoys a comfortable style of living to the standard which they would have expected had I (and their parents) remained alive, then you should use such funds for this purpose. Subject to this, once each of her children reaches the age of 30, you should take guidance from him/her (in addition to her son in relation to his/her notional family share. However, I would like you to balance providing for them in a generous way, with retaining funds in trust for the longer term benefit of her future grandchildren. I am particularly concerned to protect her children from receiving too much too young. The Trust fund should be used to maintain and enhance their quality of life, encouraging them to pursue their own ambitions and goals and support those, but to discourage them from being dependent on the Trust at the expense of their own ambitions, drive and wellbeing. If/when considering any such distributions of capital or income, or applying such capital/income for the benefit of a family member (whether her children or future grandchildren), you should bear in mind the personal circumstances of that beneficiary at the relevant time, including their needs, other resources, the tax position, protection of assets (e.g. from possible claims by creditors or in the event of divorce) and the personal position of the beneficiary himself or herself (such as age, responsibility, etc). Using these criteria for guidance, you should look to provide the benefits for that beneficiary in the most appropriate way - this may not necessarily be by way of outright distribution, but could include making loans (with or without interest), acquiring assets for the use and benefit of a beneficiary (such as a home), payment of funds on behalf of a beneficiary directly (such as for education) or by retaining funds in trust, adopting a conservative, professionally managed investment strategy to produce an appropriate amount of return in the most tax efficient and effective manner. Should either of her children die leaving issue, then you should hold the notional share of her deceased child primarily for the benefit of his or her children equally. In principle, I suggest that, up to the age of thirty, funds are used primarily for each grandchild's education (including private school fees and university), the provision of a comfortable home and any medical needs, although should there be any need to provide funds for general living expenses, to ensure that each enjoys a comfortable style of living to the standard which they would have expected had I (and their parents) remained alive, then you should use such funds for this purpose. Thereafter, you should apply the same criteria, outlined above (for her children), for each of her grandchildren. In the unlikely event that my daughter and her children die without leaving surviving issue, then I would like you to consider exercising your powers to add the children of my other daughter, as beneficiaries of the Trust. In this scenario, I would like you to treat her children as the primary beneficiaries of the Trust and take the above guidance into account, but so that references to my daughters children and descendants are read as references to my other daughters children and descendants. Going forward I would like you to treat the wishes and guidance of my daugher as if it came from me, including if she provides further guidance which differs from any of the above. Af DECLARATION OF TRUST fremgår bl.a. følgende: […] Protector's Powers THIS DECLARATION OF TRUST is made by TRUST LIMITED of […], (the "Original Trustee"). RECITALS: (A) The Original Trustee declares that the property specified in Schedule 1 (the "Initial Trust Property") shall be held on the trusts set out in this Instrument and to be known as the Trust (the "Trust") or by such other name as the Trustees may determine by instrument from time to time. (B) The Settlor intends for the Trust to be considered a separate entity from a Danish tax perspective and therefore eligible for 20 pct. duty according to section 3A of the Danish Foundation Tax Act (and therefore not covered by the Danish Tax Assessment Act Section 16K). […] 1. DEFINITIONS AND INTERPRETATION 1.1 The expressions already defined shall have the meaning already given to them and the following expressions shall have the following meanings: 1.1.1 "Beneficiaries" means the persons listed or described in Schedule 2 as well as any person or class added by instrument pursuant to the provisions of this Instrument save to the extent that any such person becomes an Excluded Person and " Beneficiary" has a corresponding meaning; 1.1.2 "child" in relation to a person means that person's son or daughter whether legitimate, illegitimate, legitimated or adopted; 1.1.3 "Civil Partner" means one of the persons to a relationship between two persons which relationship has in the opinion of the Trustees similar legal effect to a marriage and is recognised as such in any jurisdiction in which one or both of them are or have at any time been resident or domiciled; 1.1.4 "Excluded Persons" means the persons listed or described in Schedule 3 and any person declared to be an Excluded Person pursuant to the provisions of this Trust; […] 1.1.10 "Original Protector" means the person described in Schedule 4; […] 1.1.12 "person connected with a Beneficiary" means: (a) any person having any Substantial direct or indirect beneficial interest in shares of a body corporate which is a Beneficiary (where "Substantial" means more than 50 pct. of the issued shares or the ability to control the board of that body corporate); (b) any person in which any Beneficiary has a Substantial beneficial interest whether as shareholder partner or otherwise; (c) any employee of any Beneficiary or any person referred to in (a) or (b) above; or (d) any person who is the spouse issue parent brother or sister (or the spouse of any of them) of any Beneficiary or of any person referred to in (a) or (b) above; 1.1.13 "person connected with a Protector" has the same meaning as if the definition of "person with a Protector" connected with a Beneficiary" were here repeated with the substitution of "Protector" for "Beneficiary" throughout; 1.1.14 "person connected with a Trustee" has the same meaning as if the definition of "person connected with a Beneficiary" were repeated with the substitution of "Trustee" for "Beneficiary" throughout; 1.1.15 "Principal Beneficiary" means daughter of the Settlor; 1.1.16 "Proper Law" means the law governing this Trust from time to time; […] 1.1.24 “Trust Period" means […] (a) the day (if any) on which the Proper Law requires this Trust to terminate; or (b) such date as the Trustees may declare by instrument to be the date of expiration of the Trust Period, 3. TRUSTS OF INCOME AND CAPITAL 3.1 Until and subject to and in default of any payment or appointment under Clause 5.1 the Trustees shall in their sole discretion hold the Trust Fund and its income upon the following trusts: 3.1.1 the Trustees may appoint pay or apply the income of the Trust Fund to or for the benefit of all or such one or more of the Beneficiaries exclusive of the other or others of them as are then living and in such shares if more than one and in such manner generally as the Trustees shall in their absolute discretion from time to time think fit; 3.1.2 subject to the preceding Sub-Clause the Trustees may accumulate the income by investing or otherwise applying it and its resulting income from time to time in any application or investment authorised by this Trust or by the Proper Law and subject to the following Sub-Clause shall hold such accumulations as an accretion to the Trust Fund; 3.1.3 the Trustees may at any time or times apply the whole or any part or parts of the income accumulated under the preceding Sub-Clause as if it were income arising in the then current year; and 3.1.4 the Trustees may at any time appoint pay or apply the whole or any part of the Trust Fund whether or not in specie to or for the benefit of all or such one or more of the Beneficiaries exclusive of the other or others of them in such shares if more than one and in such manner generally as the Trustees shall in their absolute discretion think fit. 4. DEFAULT TRUSTS 4.1 Subject to the provisions of the preceding Clause at the expiry of the Trust Period or if the trusts of this Trust otherwise fail the Trustees shall hold the Trust Fund and its income for such of the Principal Beneficiary's children and descendants who are living and, if more than one, then in equal shares absolutely per stirpes (but so that no-one shall take whose parent is alive and so capable of taking). 4.2 Subject to Clause 4.1, the Trust Fund and its income shall be held upon trust for such of the Settlor's grandchildren and remoter issue who are living and, if more than one, then in equal shares absolutely per stirpes (but so that no-one shall take whose parent is alive and so capable of taking). 5. TRUSTEES' POWER OF APPOINTMENT 5.1 In addition to their other powers and discretions under this Trust and generally in relation to the trusts of this Trust the Trustees may, during the Trust Period and with the prior or simultaneous written consent of the Protector, in relation to the whole or any part of the capital of the Trust Fund or its income exercise their powers of appointment by declaring trusts in favour of all or any one or more of the Beneficiaries and with such provisions for maintenance education or advancement or for accumulation of income during minority or for the purpose of raising a portion or for forfeiture in the event of bankruptcy and otherwise with such administrative powers and generally in such manner in all respects as the Trustees may revocably or irrevocably by instrument appoint but so that any revocable appointment if not revoked before the expiration of the Trust Period shall become irrevocable on that date. 5.2 Any trust so appointed may be either mandatory or discretionary and may create any interest whatsoever in either the capital or income or both whether absolute or limited and whether vested or contingent and whether in possession or in reversion and whether revocable or irrevocable and may divide the capital or the income thereof or any part thereof respectively into any shares and any discretionary trusts or powers may by any such appointment be conferred upon any persons (not necessarily including the Trustees) and any such trusts or powers so conferred may authorise the delegation of any discretion or the creation of further trusts or powers. 5.3 Any trust so appointed may be in favour of any Beneficiary irrespective that such trust may also contain trusts powers and provisions in favour of other persons or objects if the Trustees shall in their discretion consider such appointment to be for the benefit of such Beneficiary and may be governed by the law of any jurisdiction and upon such appointment the Trustees shall not be bound to see to the further application of the Trust Fund so appointed. 5.4 In such appointment the Trustees shall have power to appoint separate trustees of the property of which trusts are declared thereunder and to provide for the appointment of new or additional trustees thereof so that all or any such trustees or new or additional trustees may be persons resident within or outside the jurisdiction of the Proper Law. 5.5 No payment or appointment made under this Clause shall: 5.5.1 affect any payment or application of all or any part of the Trust Fund or its income previously made under any power or discretion conferred by this Trust or by law; and 5.5.2 affect any entitlement under any of the trusts of this Trust to any income of the Trust Fund or of any part or share of the Trust Fund which accrued before such appointment was made. 5.6 No power of appointment or application conferred on the Trustees under this Clause shall authorise the appointment of the Trust Fund if any of the Excluded Persons would or might be or become a beneficiary or able to benefit (save to the extent allowed under this Instrument) under or in consequence of such appointment or application. 6. APPLICATION OF PROPERTY 6.1 For the avoidance of doubt the Trustees may in the exercise of their powers to appoint transfer pay or apply income or capital of the Trust Fund appoint transfer pay or apply any income or capital of the Trust Fund to a foundation or to the trustees of any other trust wherever established or existing under which foundation or trust at least one of the Beneficiaries is interested (whether or not there are other objects or persons interested or capable of benefiting under the foundation or the other trust) if the Trustees shall in their absolute discretion consider that such appointment transfer payment or application is for the benefit of such Beneficiary or Beneficiaries PROVIDED THAT no exercise by the Trustees of this power shall authorise any appointment transfer payment application or advance to the foundation or to the trustees of the other trust if any of the Excluded Persons would or might be or become beneficiaries or able to benefit (save to the extent allowed under this Instrument) under or by virtue of such foundation or other trust. 6.2 For the purposes of the powers conferred by this Instrument a person shall be deemed to be interested under a foundation or trust if any capital or income of the foundation or trust is or is capable of being appointed transferred paid or applied to him or for his benefit whether pursuant to the constitution of the foundation or the terms of the trust or in consequence of any decision of the foundation or in consequence of the exercise of any power or discretion conferred on the trustees of the trust by the terms of the trust or otherwise. 7. POWER TO ADD BENEFICIARIES The Trustees, with the prior or simultaneous written consent of the Protector, have power by instrument revocable during the Trust Period or irrevocable to add as Beneficiaries such one or more persons or a class of persons (none being Excluded Persons) as the Trustees shall in their absolute discretion determine subject to such terms conditions or restrictions and for such period as may be specified in such instrument and such instrument shall specify the date (not being earlier than the date of the instrument but during the Trust Period) from which such person shall be so added. 8. POWER TO REMOVE AND EXCLUDE BENEFICIARIES 8.1 The Trustees, with the prior or simultaneous written consent of the Protector, may by instrument declare that a person a class or member of a class named or specified (whether or not ascertained) in such instrument who or which is would or might but for this Clause be or become a Beneficiary or a class of Beneficiaries or be otherwise capable of benefiting under this Trust as the case may be: 8.1.1 shall be wholly or partially excluded from future benefit; or 8.1.2 shall cease to be a Beneficiary or a member of a class of Beneficiaries; or 8.1.3 shall be an Excluded Person. […] 8.3 Any Beneficiary or other person capable of benefiting under the trusts of this Trust in consequence of the exercise by the Trustees of any discretion or power who is adult and of full legal capacity shall have the power by instrument delivered to the Trustees: 8.3.1 to declare that he is no longer to be a Beneficiary or capable of benefiting and whether in respect of the whole or any part of the Trust Fund PROVIDED ALWAYS where such declaration is expressed to be revocable the same may be revoked by instrument delivered to the Trustees; or 8.3.2 irrevocably to declare that he shall be an Excluded Person. […] 12. POWER TO VARY AND RECTIFY 12.1 The Trustees, with prior or simultaneous written consent of the Protector, may by instrument vary amend add to or delete any or all of the trusts powers or provisions of this Trust in such manner in all respects as the Trustees may consider expedient or to rectify any manifest errors in this Instrument or any other instrument PROVIDED ALWAYS that: […] 13. DISCLOSURE AND CONFIDENTIALITY […] 13.2 The Trustees shall provide the Principal Beneficiary with such information and accounts concerning the Trust Fund or the trusts of this Trust to the Principal Beneficiary during her lifetime as the Principal Beneficiary may reasonably request, and following the death of the Principal Beneficiary, to the Principal Beneficiary's children as they may reasonably request. […] 13.6 The Trustees shall provide the Protector with such information and accounts concerning the Trust Fund or the trusts of this Trust as the Protector may reasonably require to enable him to carry out his functions under this Trust. […] 14. PROPER LAW AND JURISDICTION 14.1 Subject to the powers conferred on the Trustees to change the Proper Law the Proper Law of this Trust shall be the law of X and (except where the context requires otherwise) the rights of all parties and the construction and effect of each and every provision of this Instrument shall be construed and regulated according to the laws of the said the courts of which shall have exclusive jurisdiction in respect of all matters in connection with the Trust notwithstanding that one or more or all of the Trustees may from time to time be resident or domiciled or the forum for the administration of the Trust may be elsewhere than in the said. 14.2 The Trustees, with the prior or simultaneous written consent of the Protector, may by instrument declare that this Trust shall from the date of such declaration take effect in accordance with the law of any other jurisdiction in any part of the world specified in the declaration under which the terms of this Trust shall be capable of taking effect. As from the date of any such declaration the law of the place specified therein shall be the law applicable to this Trust and the courts of such place shall have exclusive jurisdiction in respect of all matters in connection with the Trust but subject to any further exercise by the Trustees of the power conferred by this Clause. […] 15. DECLARATION OF END OF TRUST PERIOD The Trustees, with the prior or simultaneous written consent of the Protector, may at any time or times by instrument declare a date to be the date of the expiration of the Trust Period. […] 17. TRUSTS IRREVOCABLE The trusts created under this Instrument shall be irrevocable. […] 19. APPOINTMENT OF TRUSTEES 19.1 The following persons shall have the power by instrument to appoint new or additional Trustees namely: 19.1.1 the Protector or if there is no Protector or the Protector shall be unwilling or incapable of acting whether by virtue of incapacity or because he cannot be found or if the Protector should fail to appoint a successor Trustee within a period of 30 days of receipt of the Trustee's notice of his wish to be discharged from trusteeship then; 19.1.2 the Trustees or if there is no surviving or continuing Trustee then; 19.1.3 the legal representative or the liquidator of the last remaining Trustee. 20. REMOVAL RETIREMENT AND DISCHARGE OF TRUSTEES 20.1 A person shall cease to be a Trustee if: […] 20.1.6 he receives written notice from the Protector removing him as a Trustee. […] 22. MINIMUM NUMBER OF TRUSTEES The minimum number of persons to be the trustees of this Trust (or any part of the Trust Fund in respect of which a separate set of trustees has been appointed) shall be one in the case of a body corporate and two in any other case. […] 30. REMUNERATION OF TRUSTEES 30.1 Any body corporate which conducts business in the provision of trust or fiduciary services and is appointed Trustee from time to time shall be entitled to charge for its services at such rate or in such manner as may from time to time be agreed with the eldest individual Beneficiary including (in addition to reimbursement of its proper expenses costs and other liabilities) the right to remuneration for its services and the incidence thereof and in addition such body corporate or any person connected with such body corporate being a banker broker investment adviser manager administrator or engaged in any other profession business or trade may without accounting for any resultant profit and without the necessity of obtaining specific authority act in such capacity and perform any service in relation to the trusts of this Trust and on the same terms including as to remuneration as with a customer. The remuneration arrangements set out in this Sub-Clause shall be reviewed with the eldest individual Beneficiary on or around each third anniversary of the creation of the Trust, or such earlier periods as the Trustees and eldest individual Beneficiary may agree. […] 33. APPOINTMENT OF PROTECTOR 33.1 The power to appoint a new or additional Protector shall be vested in the Protector for the time being by instrument executed by the Protector, the person being appointed as a new or additional Protector, and the Trustees to acknowledge the appointment. 33.2 The instrument by which a new Protector is appointed shall take effect according to its terms and without prejudice to the generality of the foregoing such appointment may take effect immediately or at some future date or on some future event or on the death or incapacity or otherwise of the then current Protector and may be revocable at any time before the appointment becomes effective. 33.3 If there shall at any time be no Protector, subject to any prior instrument executed by the Protector appointing a new or additional Protector, the power to appoint a new Protector shall be vested in the Principal Beneficiary, or if the Principal Beneficiary shall be unable or unwilling to act, in the eldest individual Beneficiary, willing and able to act. 33.4 No appointment of a Protector shall be effective if the person purportedly appointed is at the time of the appointment a Trustee (or a person connected with a Trustee) and if at any time a Trustee (or a person connected with a Trustee) would but for this SubClause be a Protector that person shall immediately cease to be a Protector. […] 35. POWERS OF PROTECTOR 35.1 Notwithstanding anything contained in this Trust to the contrary (and in particular anything conferring an absolute or uncontrolled discretion on the Trustees) the powers of the Trustees specified in Schedule 6 shall be exercised only with the prior or simultaneous written consent of the Protector which consent shall be deemed to be given only upon receipt by the Trustees of the written consent. 35.2 For the avoidance of doubt where at any time: 35.2.1 no Protector has been appointed; or 35.2.2 there is no Protector; or 35.2.3 a person ceases to be a Protector and no successor Protector is appointed, the Trustees shall be entitled to exercise the powers specified in Schedule 6 and may administer the trusts of this Trust unilaterally and free from the requirement for any consent whatsoever. […] Schedule 2 Beneficiaries The Beneficiaries shall mean: (a) the Principal Beneficiary during her lifetime; and (b) following the death of the Principal Beneficiary, the Principal Beneficiary's children. Schedule 3 Excluded Persons The following persons shall be Excluded Persons: (a) The Settlor; (b) Any Trustee unless acting in its capacity as trustee of a separate trust; and (c) Such other person or persons as may from time to time be declared by the Trustees to be an Excluded Person in accordance with clause 8 above. Schedule 4 Original Protector The Original Protector of the Trust shall be […], London Schedule 5 […] 6. NON-INCOME PRODUCING INVESTMENTS No Beneficiary shall be entitled as such Beneficiary to compel the sale or other realisation of any property comprised in the Trust Fund whether or not producing income or to insist on the investment of any part of the Trust Fund in property producing income nor to require the distribution of any dividend by any company in which the Trustees may be interested or require the Trustees to exercise any powers they may have of compelling such distribution. 7. POWER OF APPROPRIVATION The Trustees may at any time appropriate any part of the Trust Fund in its then actual state and condition in or towards satisfaction of the whole or any part of any share or beneficial interest in the Trust Fund upon making such valuation if any as the Trustees may think fit and without the consent of any Beneficiary being required for any such appropriation and so that any appropriation so made shall be final and binding on any person entitled to or who may become entitled to any interest in the Trust Fund. […] 9. POWER TO MANDATE INCOME In making any payment of income to any Beneficiary pursuant to the trusts of income of this Trust the Trustees may from time to time make arrangements (whether by a written mandate given to bankers or to any company any of whose stocks or shares or securities are for the time being comprised in the Trust Fund or otherwise howsoever) under which any income of the Trust Fund will be paid direct to any of the Beneficiaries. 10. POWER TO ACQUIRE OR DEVELOP PROPERTY The Trustees may apply any money for the time being forming part of the Trust Fund in purchasing or otherwise acquiring improving or developing any immovable or movable property of whatsoever nature and wheresoever situate including repairing replacing building erecting rebuilding demolishing extending decorating furnishing or equipping such property. 11. POWER IN RELATION TO IMMOVABLE PROPERTY The Trustees may in addition to any powers of management conferred by law upon trustees holding land sell exchange convey lease mortgage charge agree to let licence and otherwise conduct the management of any land held subject to the trusts of this Trust as if they were the absolute owners of such land. The Trustees shall not be bound to see nor (absent fraud wilful misconduct or gross negligence on the part of the Trustees) be liable or accountable for omitting or neglecting to see to the repair or insurance of any buildings on such land or any part of the land or to the payment of any outgoings in respect of the buildings and/or land but may repair and insure any such buildings in such manner and to such extent as they shall think fit and pay out of the Trust Fund or its income the costs of all such repairs and of effecting and keeping up any such insurance and any such outgoings as aforesaid and in the case of payments out of the income of the Trust Fund in priority to any other trusts affecting the same income. 12. POWER TO PERMIT PERSONS TO USE AND ENJOY PROPERTY The Trustees may permit any person to occupy or reside in or upon or have the custody use and enjoyment of any immovable or movable property (as the case may be) which or the proceeds of sale of which for the time being may be held upon the trusts of this Trust upon such terms and conditions as to payment of rent rates taxes and other expenses and outgoings and as to insurance repair and decoration and generally for such periods and upon such terms and conditions as the Trustees think fit including gratuitously. 13. POWER TO BORROW The Trustees may borrow from any person whether on the security of the Trust Fund (or any part of the Trust Fund) or otherwise for any purpose (including the making of investments to be held as part of the Trust Fund) and on such terms (whether as to payment of interest or otherwise) as the Trustees think fit. 14. POWER TO CHARGE PROPERTY The Trustees may assign pledge charge mortgage hypothecate or otherwise encumber either within or outside the jurisdiction of the Proper Law the whole or any part of the Trust Fund by way of security for any borrowing or guarantee or other obligation made given or incurred by the Trustees in connection with the trusts of this Trust or by any Beneficiary or by any person connected with a Beneficiary. […] 24. POWER TO ACT AS DIRECTORS AND EMPLOYEES OF COMPANIES The Trustees may act as director or other officer or employee of any company in which any part of the Trust Fund may be invested either within or outside the jurisdiction of the Proper Law and may retain any fees or other remuneration received in respect of any such directorship office or employment notwithstanding that it is held by virtue of votes attaching to the Trustees' holding any shares or stock in such company. […] 34. POWER TO LEND OR HIRE OUT PROPERTY The Trustees may lend let or hire any money or other property to any person (whether or not such person is a Beneficiary hereunder) either gratuitously or upon such terms and for such period as the Trustees shall think fit provided that no loan shall be made on terms whereby repayment shall be postponed beyond the expiration of the Trust Period and where any money or other property is so lent let or hired the Trustees shall not (absent fraud wilful misconduct or gross negligence on the part of the Trustees) be responsible for any loss or damage to the same howsoever incurred. […] 38. POWER TO PAY TAXES The Trustees may pay or apply the whole or part of the Trust Fund or its income in discharging or settling any duty fee tax or levy of whatsoever nature and wheresoever arising becoming payable in any part of the world in respect of the Trust Fund (or any part of the Trust Fund) or any income or in respect of any property transferred by or to or under the control of the Trustees or any person interested under the trusts of this Trust or in respect of the trusteeship of this Trust notwithstanding that such duty fee tax or levy is or may not be recoverable from the Trustees by legal process in the forum for the administration of this Trust or elsewhere and notwithstanding that such payment may be to the advantage or in the interest of the Trustees and no person interested under this Trust shall be entitled to make any claim whatsoever against the Trustees by reason of their making such payment. Den [dato udeladt] bad Skattestyrelsen om følgende oplysninger: - Følgende fremgår af Schedule 4: “ The Original Protector of the Trust shall be “A" ". Det ønskes oplyst, hvilken relation Spørger har til protektoren - enten privat eller erhvervsmæssigt. - Hvad er stifterens relation til den/de nuværende trustees? - Bliver trusten beskattet som et selvstændigt skattesubjekt i X-land, hvor den p.t. er hjemmehørende? - Hvis enheden beskattes som et selvstændig skattesubjekt i udlandet, hvordan bliver den så beskattet? [Samme dato] svarede rådgiver følgende: Hermed svar på jeres anmodning om yderligere oplysninger. 1. Der er ingen familiemæssig eller øvrig personlig relation mellem Spørger og "A". "A" er advokat. 2. Der er ej heller nogen relation mellem Spørger og trustee. Trustee er forpligtet til at administrere trusten i overensstemmelse med stiftelsesdokumentet og "letter of wishes" 3. Trusten beskattes ikke i X-land. [Samme dato] bad Skattestyrelsen om følgende oplysninger: Bare for at være sikker, når du skriver, at trusten ikke beskattes i X-land, så betyder det, at den slet ikke er et skattesubjekt i X-land? [Samme dato] svarede rådgiver følgende: Trusten indgiver ingen selvangivelse i X-land, da sådanne enheder ikke beskattes i X-land. Jeg ved ikke, om det besvarer dit spørgsmål. Uanset hvad, kan jeg ikke se, hvordan den udenlandske skattemæssige behandling - eller mangel på samme - er relevant i forhold til vurderingen af om indskud fra Spørger til Trusten omfattes af fondsbeskatningsloven § 3 A. Når denne vurdering skal foretages, skal der jo udelukkende ses på om Spørger har givet endeligt og uigenkaldeligt afkald på de midler, der er indskudt i trusten (hvilket helt klart er tilfældet i sagen her). Jeg skal for god ordens skyld gøre opmærksom på, at koncipering af stiftelsesdokumenterne er foretaget med henblik på opfyldelse af fondsbeskatningsloven § 3 A. [Samme dato] skrev Skattestyrelsen følgende til rådgiver: Jeg skal igen anmode om at få oplyst, om trusten beskattes som et selvstændigt skattesubjekt i X-land. At den ikke beskattes, er jo ikke nødvendigvis det samme, som at den ikke er et selvstændigt skattesubjekt. Hvis spørgsmålet ikke besvares, må jeg overveje at afvise dine spørgsmål. [Samme dato] svarede rådgiver følgende: Trustee har oplyst, at Trusten ikke beskattes som et selvstændigt skattesubjekt i X-land. Beskatning sker hos trustee, da trustee anses for juridisk ejer af de underliggende aktiver (hvilket aktuelt blot er en mindre kontantbeholdning). [En efterfølgende dato] svarede rådgiver følgende: Sktst spørgsmål : Kan Spørger, efter at hun har underskrevet letter of Wishes, fortsat selv give trustee ønsker og vejledning om trusten eller er det derefter alene hendes datter, der kan give ønsker og vejledning til trustee? [Rådgiver] svar : Spørger kan ikke instruere beneficiary eller trustee i hvordan trustens formue skal forvaltes. Spørger kan ej heller på nogen måde modtage midler fra trusten eller foranledige ændring af trustens vedtægter, så hun kan modtage sådanne midler. Sktst spørgsmål : Og kan Spørger, efter at hun har underskrevet letter of Wishes, ændre disse igen? [Rådgiver] svar : Spørger kan i princippet udfærdige og underskrive yderligere "letter of wishes", men hverken beneficiary eller trustee har pligt til at følge disse, jf. vores svar på det første spørgsmål. Spørgers opfattelse og begrundelse Vi mener, at spørgsmål 1 og 2 begge skal besvares med "Ja". Som anført, er det Spørgers ønske, at indskuddene omfattes af fondsbeskatningslovens § 3 A, stk. 1 og trustens stiftelsesdokumenter mv. er udarbejdet i overensstemmelse med dette. Det er vores opfattelse, at Trusten opfylder betingelserne i fondsbeskatningslovens § 3 A, stk. 1, herunder at trusten er stiftet i et land, hvor fonde eller truster beskattes væsentligt lavere end efter danske regler samt at Spørger har givet endeligt og uigenkaldeligt afkald på de midler, der er indskudt i trusten. Følgelig skal afkastet af trustens formue ikke beskattes hos Spørger efter ligningslovens § 16 K. Som følge af ovenstående, skal Spørgers indskud til Trusten pålægges 20 pct. afgift efter fondsbeskatningslovens § 3 A. Skattestyrelsens indstilling og begrundelse Spørgsmål 1 Det ønskes bekræftet, at Spørgers indskud i Trusten omfattes af fondsbeskatningslovens § 3 A, stk. 1. Begrundelse I henhold til fondsbeskatningslovens § 3 A, stk. 1, skal bl.a. en skattepligtig omfattet af kildeskattelovens § 1, som indskyder midler i en udenlandsk trust, som er stiftet eller oprettet i et land, hvor fonde eller truster beskattes væsentlig lavere end efter danske regler, betale en afgift på 20 pct. af indskuddet. Dette gælder dog kun den del af de årlige indskud, der overstiger 10.000 kr. I henhold til fondsbeskatningslovens § 3 A, stk. 2, finder stk. 1 ikke anvendelse, såfremt indskyderen godtgør, at midlerne i den udenlandske fond eller trust anvendes i almenvelgørende eller på anden måde almennyttigt øjemed til fordel for en større kreds af personer eller hvis indskyderen som følge af indskuddet er skattepligtig af afkastet i den udenlandske fond eller trust, jf. ligningslovens § 16 K. Faktiske oplysninger Spørger er fuldt skattepligtig til Danmark. Både trustee og protektor er uafhængige i forhold til Spørger, som har stiftet trusten. Af et letter of Wishes fra Spørger fremgår bl.a. følgende: “STRICTLY PRIVATE AND CONFIDENTIAL To the Trustees of the Trust LETTER OF WISHES I am the Settlor of the Trust made between: (i) me and (ii) Trust Limited (the "Trust"). […] Going forward I would like you to treat the wishes and guidance of my daughter as if it came from me, including if she provides further guidance which differs from any of the above." Det er desuden oplyst, at Spørger i princippet kan udfærdige og underskrive yderligere "letter of wishes". Skattemæssig vurdering For så vidt angår trusts er der skabt en langvarig praksis, hvorefter fx udenlandske familietrusts i udgangspunktet kan tillægges selvstændig skattesubjektivitet efter dansk skatteret, hvis trustkapitalen er definitivt og effektivt udskilt fra stifteren, jf. Den juridiske vejledning 2025-1, afsnit C. B. 2.15.2 . Begrebet definitivt indebærer, at stifteren ikke må have mulighed for at tilbagekalde kapitalen, således at kapitalen igen indgår i stifterens formuesfære. Begrebet effektivt indebærer, at stifteren ikke må have fortsat rådighed over den udskilte kapital. Efter praksis indebærer dette bl.a., at de midler, der er overført til den udenlandske trust, ikke må kunne føres tilbage til stifteren, dennes ægtefælle eller hjemmeboende børn under 18. Dette gælder for både enhedens kapital og afkastet af denne. Det vil sige, at midlerne skal være overført til enheden på en sådan måde, at stifteren helt er afskåret fra at kunne råde over disse. SKM2020. 427. LSR drejede sig om, hvorvidt en trust kunne anerkendes som et selvstændigt skattesubjekt i henhold til fondsbeskatningslovens § 3 A. Landsskatteretten bemærkede, at det i henhold til praksis var en forudsætning for at anse en udenlandsk trust som et selvstændigt skattesubjekt, at midlerne i trusten definitivt og effektivt var udskilt fra stifterens formuesfære. Henset til, at protektor var tildelt en række vidtrækkende beføjelser i forhold til trustens ledelse, herunder at kunne udpege og afsætte begunstigede, og at protektor havde underskrevet sin egen opsigelse, fandt Landsskatteretten det ikke godtgjort, at trusten havde en uafhængig ledelse set i forhold til klageren som stifter. Landsskatteretten fandt efter en samlet konkret vurdering ikke, at der var sket en effektiv og uigenkaldelig udskillelse af kapitalen i trusten fra klagerens formue, hvorfor det var med rette, at trusten ikke var tillagt skattesubjektivitet i forhold til dansk skatteret. Fondsbeskatningslovens § 3 A kunne derfor ikke finde anvendelse. I nærværende sag er både trustee og protektor uafhængige i forhold til stifteren, hvilket umiddelbart kunne give det indtryk, at trusten er et selvstændigt skattesubjekt. Af bl.a. lovforslag nr. 167 af 20. februar 2015 (bl.a. skattelypakke om trusts), hvor ligningslovens § 16 K blev indført, fremgik bl.a. følgende af de almindelige bemærkninger: "Det væsentligste spørgsmål i forbindelse med trusts er, om formuen reelt er definitivt og effektivt udskilt fra stifterens formuesfære. Dette er afgørende for, om stifteren fortsat beskattes af afkastet fra trustens formue. Stifteren skal således fortsat beskattes af formueafkastet, hvis formuen ikke definitivt og effektivt er udskilt. I forhold til skatteunddragelse er det væsentligste problem, at det i praksis kan være meget vanskeligt for SKAT at opdage - og derefter bevise - at stifteren har bevaret rådigheden over trustens formue. Det synes således muligt for stifteren at hemmeligholde, at formuen er genkaldelig. Dette kan f.eks. gøres ved at udstede et underhåndsbrev (letter of wishes) til trustee. Underhåndsbrevet er formelt set ikke bindende for trustee, men kan reelt blive det, hvis der samtidigt indsættes en såkaldt protector med vide beføjelser til f.eks. at afsætte trustee. Protector kan således drage omsorg for, at trustee i sin administration af trusten følger stifterens underhåndsbrev." I SKM2021. 211. HR var det oplyst, at i perioden fra 10. december 1990 til 28. december 2006 fulgte det af den såkaldte Contract of Mandate, at A og NM inden for rammerne af loven, trustens vedtægter og "social or professional ethics and standings" havde fuld instruktionsret over for de øvrige medlemmer af bestyrelsen. For den efterfølgende periode forelå der ikke nærmere oplysninger om kompetenceforholdene i bestyrelsen. Herefter og efter bevisførelsen i øvrigt lagde Højesteret til grund, at fonden ikke på noget tidspunkt inden As død har haft en uafhængig ledelse. Højesteret fandt efter det anførte, at fonden ikke i forhold til A kunne anses for et selvstændigt skattesubjekt, og at dens værdier derfor måtte anses for efterladt af ham. Det kunne ikke tillægges betydning, at boet på grund af fondskonstruktionen efter det oplyste ikke kunne komme i besiddelse af fondens værdier. Det er Skattestyrelsens opfattelse, at da Spørger i nærværende sag kan ændre letter of wishes, så længe hun lever, så er trusten transparent i forhold til Spørger. At trusten er transparent i forhold til Spørger understøttes i øvrigt også af, at trustee skal tage imod vejledning fra Spørger og /eller datteren, og at trustee, ifølge trustens vedtægt, skal holde datteren orienteret om trustens forhold. Efter Skattestyrelsens opfattelse, må trusten derfor anses for transparent i forhold til Spørger, i og med at hun kan udarbejde et nyt letter of wishes og Spørger eller datteren efter ordlyden af letter of wishes kan instruere trustee. Det er således Skattestyrelsens opfattelse, at trusten ikke kan anses som et selvstændigt skattesubjekt, men er transparent i forhold til Spørger. Da fondsbeskatningslovens § 3 A kun finder anvendelse, hvis den trust der overføres midler til kan anses for et selvstændigt skattesubjekt, kan spørgsmålet ikke bekræftes, da trusten ikke anses for et selvstændigt skattesubjekt. Indstilling Skattestyrelsen indstiller, at spørgsmål 1 besvares med "Nej". Spørgsmål 2 Det ønskes bekræftet, at ligningsloven § 16 K ikke finder anvendelse for Spørger i forhold til afkast på aktiver indskudt i Trusten. Begrundelse I henhold til ligningslovens § 16 K skal skattepligtige omfattet af bl.a. kildeskattelovens § 1, som har stiftet og indskudt aktiver i en trust på et tidspunkt, hvor den skattepligtige var fuldt skattepligtig her til landet, medregne trustens indkomst ved opgørelsen af den skattepligtige indkomst, når indkomsten i trusten er positiv. Bestemmelsen i ligningslovens § 16 K finder dog kun anvendelse, hvis trusten anses for et selvstændigt skattesubjekt efter dansk skatteret. Dette fremgår af Skatteministeriets svar til FSR, jf. lovforslag L167, FT 2014/15, bilag 1 pp. 32-35. Anerkendes trusten ikke skattemæssigt, skal der som hidtil ske en beskatning af trustformuen som en del af stifterens egen formue. I SKM2017. 568. SR bekræftede Skatterådet, at en amerikansk trust stiftet af en dansk skattepligtig skulle anses for skattemæssigt transparent, således at der ikke skulle ske beskatning efter ligningslovens § 16 K, og således at overdragelser til trusten ikke ansås for en skattemæssig afståelse, ligesom stifteren fortsat var skattepligtig af afkastet mv. af de indskudte aktiver i trusten, samt at udbetalinger til begunstigede i udgangspunktet ansås for gaver. Af begrundelsen under spørgsmål 1 fremgår, at trusten i nærværende sag er transparent i forhold til Spørger. Da Trusten er transparent i forholdt til Spørger, finder ligningslovens § 16 K ikke anvendelse. Det kan derfor bekræftes, at ligningsloven § 16 K ikke finder anvendelse for Spørger i forhold til afkast på aktiver indskudt i Trusten. Skattestyrelsen bemærker, at da trusten er transparet i forhold til Spørger, skal Spørger fortsat beskattes af afkast på aktiverne i trusten, da alle aktiverne anses for fortsat at henhøre under Spørgers formuesfære. Indstilling Skattestyrelsen indstiller, at spørgsmål 2 besvares med "Ja". Skatterådets afgørelse og begrundelse Skatterådet tiltræder Skattestyrelsens indstilling og begrundelse. Lovgrundlag, forarbejder og praksis Spørgsmål 1 Lovgrundlag Fondsbeskatningsloven § 1 Skattepligt i henhold til denne lov omfatter: […] 4) Fonde, truster og andre selvejende institutioner, der er oprettet i udlandet, på Færøerne eller i Grønland, hvis ledelsen har sæde her i landet. Dette gælder, uanset hvor fonden, trusten eller den selvejende institution eventuelt er indregistreret. En trust, der efter udenlandske regler må anses for at udgøre et selvstændigt skattesubjekt, men som efter danske regler ikke anses for at udgøre et selvstændigt skattesubjekt, omfattes endvidere af bestemmelsen, hvis trusten ville have haft ledelsens sæde her i landet, hvis den havde været et selvstændigt skattesubjekt i Danmark, jf. 1. pkt. 1. og 3. pkt. gælder dog ikke, hvis trustens indkomst beskattes efter ligningslovens § 16 K, hvis der er betalt indskudsafgift af kapitalen efter § 3 A, eller hvis der er betalt båndlæggelsesafgift efter § 3 C. Stk. 2. Skattepligten efter stk. 1, nr. 1, omfatter ikke fonde omfattet af pensionsafkastbeskatningsloven eller fonde, der udbyder pensionsordninger omfattet af pensionsafkastbeskatningslovens § 1, stk. 1. Fondsbeskatningslovens § 3 A Såfremt en skattepligtig omfattet af kildeskattelovens § 1, dødsboskattelovens § 1, stk. 2, selskabsskattelovens § 1 eller fondsbeskatningslovens § 1 indskyder midler i en udenlandsk fond eller trust, som er stiftet eller oprettet i et land, hvor fonde eller truster beskattes væsentlig lavere end efter danske regler, svarer indskyderen en afgift på 20 pct. af indskuddet. Dette gælder dog kun den del af de årlige indskud, der overstiger 10.000 kr. Stk. 2. Stk. 1 finder ikke anvendelse, såfremt indskyderen godtgør, at midlerne i den udenlandske fond eller trust anvendes i almenvelgørende eller på anden måde almennyttigt øjemed til fordel for en større kreds af personer. Stk. 1 finder ikke anvendelse, hvis indskyderen som følge af indskuddet er skattepligtig af afkastet i den udenlandske fond eller trust, jf. ligningslovens § 16 K. Stk. 1 finder ikke anvendelse ved indskud af aktier i en udenlandsk fond, når overdragelsen er omfattet af aktieavancebeskatningslovens §§ 35 C-35 F. Stk. 3. Indskud, der foretages af udenlandske selskaber og foreninger m.v., hvormed en afgiftspligtig omfattet af stk. 1 har en forbindelse som omhandlet i ligningslovens § 2, anses for foretaget af den afgiftspligtige. Stk. 4. Stk. 1-3 finder tilsvarende anvendelse på afgiftspligtige, som bliver fuldt skattepligtige efter en af de i stk. 1 nævnte bestemmelser, såfremt de tidligere har været omfattet af en af disse bestemmelser og inden for de sidste 5 år forud for den fulde skattepligts genindtræden har foretaget indskud i en udenlandsk fond eller trust som nævnt i stk. 1. Indskud anses i disse tilfælde for foretaget ved den fulde skattepligts genindtræden. Stk. 5. En udenlandsk fond eller trust anses tillige for beskattet væsentlig lavere end efter danske regler, hvis der er indgået en aftale om skattesats eller beskatningsgrundlag med skattemyndighederne i den stat, hvori den er hjemmehørende, herunder efter bestemmelserne i en dobbeltbeskatningsoverenskomst, eller hvis skattereglerne i den pågældende stat er indrettet efter, hvor indskyderen er hjemmehørende. Stk. 6. Indskudsafgiften forfalder til betaling, når indskuddet foretages. Indskyderen skal samtidig give meddelelse til told- og skatteforvaltningen om det afgiftspligtige indskud. Indbetalingen anses for rettidig, når den finder sted senest en måned efter forfaldsdagen. Betales indskudsafgiften ikke rettidigt, skal der betales rente efter § 7, stk. 1, jf. stk. 2, i opkrævningsloven. Fondsbeskatningslovens § 3 C En skattepligtig omfattet af § 1, kildeskattelovens § 1, dødsboskattelovens § 1, stk. 2, eller selskabsskattelovens § 1, som båndlægger kapital uden aktuel kapitalejer eller rentenyder, hvorefter der hverken i udlandet eller her i landet sker løbende beskatning af hele eller dele af afkastet af den båndlagte kapital, skal svare en afgift på 20 pct. af det beløb, der båndlægges. Afgiften beregnes dog kun af den del af de årlige båndlæggelser, der overstiger 10.000 kr. Stk. 2. I stedet for betaling af den i stk. 1 nævnte afgift kan båndlæggeren eller administratoren vælge, at kapitalen beskattes efter de regler, der gælder for fonde, truster og andre selvejende institutioner omfattet af § 1, stk. 1, nr. 4. Det er en betingelse for beskatning efter 1. pkt., at meddelelse om valget sker samtidig med meddelelse efter stk. 4, 1. pkt. Stk. 3. Stk. 1 og 2 finder tilsvarende anvendelse på afgiftspligtige, som bliver fuldt skattepligtige efter en af de i stk. 1 nævnte bestemmelser, såfremt den pågældende tidligere har været omfattet af en af disse bestemmelser og inden for de sidste 5 år forud for den fulde skattepligts genindtræden har båndlagt aktiver som nævnt i stk. 1. Båndlæggelsen anses i disse tilfælde for foretaget ved den fulde skattepligts genindtræden. Stk. 4. Båndlæggeren, dødsboet eller administratoren skal give meddelelse til told- og skatteforvaltningen om den båndlagte kapital på tidspunktet for båndlæggelsen. Afgiften efter stk. 1 forfalder til betaling, når båndlæggelsen foretages. Afgiften betales af båndlæggeren, båndlæggerens dødsbo eller administratoren. Indbetalingen anses for rettidig, når den finder sted senest 1 måned efter forfaldsdagen. Betales afgiften ikke rettidigt, skal der betales rente efter opkrævningslovens § 7, stk. 1, jf. stk. 2. Stk. 5. En skattepligtig omfattet af kildeskattelovens § 1, som modtager kapital, der hidtil har været båndlagt, og som hverken her i landet eller i udlandet har været beskattet af det løbende afkast af den båndlagte kapital, eller der har været betalt afgift af efter stk. 1, skal svare en afgift af den udbetalte kapital på 20 pct.36 1. pkt. finder alene anvendelse, hvis båndlæggeren tidligere har været fuldt skattepligtig her til landet og båndlæggelsen er sket inden for en periode på 5 år efter ophør af den fulde skattepligt her til landet. Afgift beregnes dog kun af den del af den årligt modtagne kapital, der overstiger 10.000 kr. Afgiften forfalder til betaling, når kapitalen modtages. Den skattepligtige skal samtidig give meddelelse til told- og skatteforvaltningen om den modtagne kapital. Stk. 4, 4. og 5. pkt., finder tilsvarende anvendelse. Stk. 6. Stk. 1-5 gælder dog ikke for gravstedskonti. Boafgiftslovens § 25 Der skal betales gaveafgift, hvis enten giver eller modtager har hjemting her i landet. Selv om giver eller modtager ikke har hjemting her i landet, skal der betales gaveafgift, hvis gaven består af aktiver af den i § 9, stk. 2, nævnte art beliggende her i landet. Forarbejder LFF nr. 167 af 20. februar 2015 Forslag til lov om ændring af ligningsloven, boafgiftsloven, fondsbeskatningsloven, skatteforvaltningsloven og forskellige andre love (bl.a. skattelypakke om trusts) […] Til § 3 Til nr. 1 Fondsbeskatningslovens § 3 A indebærer, at der ved indskud foretaget af en fuldt skattepligtig person til en lavtbeskattet udenlandsk trust (eller fond) skal betales en indskudsafgift på 20 pct. Indskudsafgiften pålægges dog kun den del, der overstiger 10.000 kr. Det foreslås, at fondsbeskatningslovens § 3 A ikke finder anvendelse, når den foreslåede bestemmelse i ligningslovens § 16 K om beskatning af stifteren af trusts m.v., jf. lovforslagets § 1, nr. 2, finder anvendelse. LF 118 af 6. december 1995 Forslag til Lov om ændring af forskellige skattelove (International sambeskatning m.v.) […] Til § 6 Til nr. 1 Den foreslåede bestemmelse pålægger personer, selskaber og fonde, der er fuldt skattepligtige i Danmark, at betale en afgift på 34 pct., når de foretager indskud i lavtbeskattede fonde eller trusts, der er stiftet eller oprettet i udlandet. Der fastsættes dog to undtagelser hertil. For det første skal der kun betales afgift af den del af det årlige indskud, der overstiger 10.000 kr. For det andet kan der opnås dispensation fra afgiften, såfremt indskyderen dokumenterer, at midlerne i den udenlandske fond eller trust anvendes i almenvelgørende eller på anden måde almennyttigt øjemed til fordel for en større kreds af personer. Reglen har til formål at sikre dansk beskatning, når en person, et selskab eller en fond m.v., der er fuldt skattepligtig i Danmark, indskyder midler i en af de nævnte udenlandske fonde eller trusts. Ved at foretage sådanne indskud vil indskyderen kunne unddrage afkastet af midlerne fra dansk beskatning. Samtidigt vil indskyderen i mange tilfælde kunne bestemme, hvordan de indskudte midler og afkastet heraf skal fordeles fremover. Den foreslåede bestemmelse skal reducere de skattemæssige incitamenter for danske selskaber, personer m.v. til at overføre aktiver til lavtbeskattede fonde og trusts i udlandet for derved at undgå en normal beskatning af afkastet. Afgiften udløses, når der indskydes midler i en fond eller trust, som er stiftet eller oprettet i et fremmed land, Færøerne eller Grønland, og fonde eller trustee i det pågældende land beskattes væsentlig lavere end i Danmark. […] Mange lavskattelande har indført særlige regelsæt om fonde og trusts, der gør oprettelse og henlæggelse af midler til fonde og trusts nemt og relativt billigt. På grund af den frie bevægelighed for kapital er det samtidigt uproblematisk at overføre midler til sådanne enheder. Såfremt der foreligger en reel adskillelse mellem midlerne i en udenlandsk fond eller trust og den danske indskyders øvrige midler, samtidigt med at midlerne er unddraget den danske stifters fremtidige rådighed, vil adskillelsen blive anerkendt i skattemæssig henseende. Derfor vil afkastet i den udenlandske fond eller trust ikke skulle henregnes til indskyderens skattepligtige indkomst, ligesom midlerne ikke vil indgå i grundlaget for formueskatten. På trods af, at midlerne er adskilt fra indskyderens formue, vil indskyderen ofte have meget stor indflydelse på fondens aktivitet. Ydermere vil en del af fondens afkast kunne tilgå familie. Dansk fondsbeskatning herunder 20 pct.'s afgiften ved stiftelse af familiefonde -kan derfor uden videre omgås ved stiftelse af fonde i lavskattelande. Afgiften udløses som udgangspunkt ved ethvert indskud i en lavtbeskattet udenlandsk fond eller trust. Dog skal der ikke betales afgift, hvis de årlige indskud ikke overstiger 10.000 kr. Endvidere vil indskyderen kunne ansøge om dispensation fra afgiften, såfremt indskuddet foretages i en almenvelgørende eller på anden vis almenvelnyttig udenlandsk fond eller trust. Det er op til indskyderen at dokumentere, at den udenlandsk fond eller trust anvender sine midler til almenvelgørende eller almennyttige formål. Det kan eksempelvis ske ved, at indskyderen fremlægger vedtægter og regnskaber fra fonden eller trusten. Der kan dog alene lægges vægt på vedtægter o.lign., hvis de afspejler den reelle aktivitet. […] I relation til bestemmelsen anses en fond som en selvejende og selvstændig juridisk enhed. Afgrænsningen af, hvornår der foreligger en fond eller ej, er derfor overensstemmende med den fondsdefinition, som i øvrigt anvendes i Danmark . Det er en betingelse for reglens anvendelse, at fonden i det land, hvor den er oprettet, beskattes efter regler, som adskiller sig væsentligt fra de danske. I modsætning til fonde er trusts ikke selvstændige juridiske personer. Ikke desto mindre anerkendes overførsel af midler til en trust i skattemæssig henseende. Det hænger sammen med, at der ved en truststiftelse normalt vil foregå en overdragelse af formuegenstande til et skattesubjekt, der ikke er hjemmehørende i Danmark. De enkelte staters eller lavskattezoners trustregler kan være meget varierende. Der er dog visse fællestræk, som går igen de fleste steder. I den typiske trust optræder tre persongrupper. En stifter, en bestyrer og nogle begunstigede. Som oftest opstilles der ikke egentlige formkrav - såsom registrering og lignende i offentlige registre - til truststiftelser, men der vil normalt skulle foreligge et stiftelsesdokument. Etablering af trusten f

    Teksten fortsætter i den officielle kilde.

    Relaterede guides, FAQ og kontraktskabeloner